", "The way in which the fat is incorporated will affect the item's overall texture. Pie crusts incorporate solid pieces of butter into the dough, which become layers of fat that are melted away during baking, leaving a flaky texture. Butter imparts a yellow tinge when used in icing, but has great flavor. | Allrecipes Taste is the obvious difference as butter produces a more flavorful cake. So, as I pretty much already knew even before running the tests, for a pound cake, butter is the only way to go. Baking Cookies: Shortening vs. The problem with the shortening made today is that it often leaves a waxy taste and film in your mouth.". During baking these tiny air pockets expand and aerate the dough, causing it to rise and spread. Shortening or butter - which is better for baking and why have we used different fats in recipes over the years? The temperature of butter matters, too, which is why you get different cookie textures depending on if you melt or soften butter before adding it to cookie dough and why you want your butter as cold as possible for the best biscuits and pie crusts. "Baked goods made with butter will not leave a greasy after taste and feel in your mouth because butter melts below body temperature. Fats that are rubbed or rolled into doughs tend to separate the dough into large layers, creating a flaky texture. Butter. Also, shortening is 100% fat, while butter contains a bit of water, which lowers its melting point, which affects the cake’s tenderness (softness) and its rise. Shortening also has a higher melting point (it's a semi-solid at room temperature), which means that cookies turn out taller because the eggs and flour have more time to set before the fat melts. Substituting unsalted butter for other fats such as shortening and oil is both simpler and more complicated. When you flip through our vintage cookbooks you'll notice the majority of recipes call for shortening, while most of today's recipes use butter. Unlike butter, shortening doesn't have a ton of flavor, but it's great for making baked goods super flaky. Cookies made with shortening are higher and lighter than cookies made with butter which are flatter and crisper. Butter vs shortening in cakes? Oil vs Butter. Butter melts, but shortening never would." When you cream shortening and sugar together, the shortening will hold more air bubbles than butter, so you get more lift, which is a big part of fluffiness. Vegetable shortening can be a mysterious ingredient. It's cheaper than butter and because it's shelf-stable, keeps longer. Shortening is 100 percent fat and no water, usually made from hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil. A cake recipe that was formulated to work with shortening wouldn’t turn out the same if you substituted butter. About last night...#buttercookies #homemade #lowcarbliving #lowcarbdiet #lowcarb #lowcarblifestyle #lowcarbtreat #lowcarbDessert #lowcarbcookies #sugarFree #lowcarbbaking #almondflour #foodporn, A post shared by JoHoScorp (@johoscorp) on May 4, 2020 at 5:58am PDT. A footnote on margarine: Chef Eddy does not recommend using margarine in baked good recipes as the fat content can vary dramatically. Cakes made with oil tend to be very moist and also tender, think Carrot Cake. Which you choose depends on personal preference, although shortening and butter are not completely interchangeable. There's no dairy in it, so if you're dairy-free, it's a good fat to use. Some of my colleagues think oil cakes age better than butter cakes, becoming more moist and tender as the days go by, but Beranbaum attributes that not to the type of fat used in the cake… Butter is known for its flavor profile, oil for moisture provision, shortening for aeration and margarine a combination of attributes. If it's a cake or quick bread, you can swap shortening, butter and oil, though there will be some taste and texture differences. Something went wrong while submitting the form. Only butter contains water (shortening does not) which turns into steam in the oven and consequently into delicate flaky layers. Differences between vegetable shortening vs butter. On the other hand, butter isn't a pure fat, but usually contains about 15 percent water. Shortening is sold in cans and easier-to-measure sticks. The main reason was simply cost. This article was originally published on November 23, 2016. "Shortening is solid at room temperature. This is a tale of two fats, saturated and unsaturated. Banana Chocolate Chip Quick Oat Cookies! Never margarine or shortening. It's made through a hydrogenation process which involves adding extra hydrogen atoms to the vegetable fats, which turns them into solids. While shortening is 100% fat, margarine and butter contain a small percentage of water (so, shortening adds more fat, thus more richness and tenderness). Shortening. Much like sugar, butter and shortening are best consumed in moderation. Nothing beats the flavor of butter, but shortening makes a taller, moisture cake. I use a high-ratio shortening from a bakery supply store, which I understand to be the trans fat variety, like lard, which was the original shortening. While you would never use liquid oil in cookies or pie crusts, vegetable oil is brilliant in cakes and quick bread. It has a lower smoke point, and will burn fairly quickly in heat," Castle says. Due to butter's lower melting point, it's important to chill your butter (and even your utensils) when working with a butter dough. ½ cup butter use ½ cup shortening plus, if desired, ⅛ tsp. That means your baked good ends up lighter as well. Shortening has no dairy in it at all, which makes it an option for those who can’t have dairy. Unlike shortening' vegetable origins, butter comes from cows' milk. Shortening doesn't really taste like anything (even the shortening with butter flavoring), which can be a pro or con depending on what you're baking. © Copyright 2020, WOS, Inc. All Rights Reserved. By definition, fats such as lard and margarine fall into this category, but today the term ‘shortening’ can simply refer to vegetable shortening. Many pie dough recipes use a combination of butter and vegetable shortening as fats. Lard is rendered pork fat and some cooks swear by it for the best pie crusts, though only if you can find pure leaf lard. On the spookiest night of the year, everyone loves a good piece of candy. Which Fat Is Better For Baking? Shortening or Butter? When using butter, you must cream the butter and sugar properly, check out How to Cream Butter and Sugar for more information. We wondered whether clarified butter or ghee, a type of clarified butter popular in Indian cooking, might make a worthy substitute in pie dough. Butter, shortening and lard are … Butter is also fat, but also has milk and water in it. Hydrogenated vegetable shortening has a melting point between 117°F - 119°F. Because baking is all about chemistry, sometimes that ingredient can be swapped and sometimes it can't. It's also important to note that unsalted butter has a higher water content, meaning it forms more stable air pockets when creamed. It’s not always a straight one to one substitution, there are several things to consider when deciding to use butter or oil. Many dough recipes are leavened by creaming butter and sugar together, introducing air pockets into the fat. The verdict? 1 cup butter use 1 cup shortening plus, if desired, ¼ tsp. When substituting shortening for butter, you may need to add extra flavoring such as almond, vanilla, cinnamon or mint extracts as shortening has no taste. It all comes down to the fat. When substituting shortening for butter, you may need to add extra flavoring such as almond, vanilla, cinnamon or mint extracts as shortening has no taste. Margarine and butter can both be used as a substitute for shortening, though their moisture contents should be taken into consideration before making the swap. It’s part of what makes these pumpkin whoopie pies so delectable. However I have a recipe for a white cake, however since it is a white cake I have really considered using white shortening instead of butter. There’s no water in shortening, so there’s no gluten-producing steam. I mean, it's butter. When it comes to baking and cookies, two fats that seem to find their way into most recipes are butter and shortening. If it's a cookie recipe, you can use shortening, lard or butter, unless it's for something like shortbread where you want to use only high-quality butter. I also have clear vanilla extract since I want my cake to be snow white. As a preface, shortening is a fat that is semi-solid or solid at room temperature. Fat works to add moisture to your cookies and allows them to come together and create a tasty end result. fork slides through a slice of shortening-based cake easier than one It's also lighter than butter: a cup of melted butter weighs about 227 grams, while a cup of vegetable oil weighs about 218 grams. If your recipe needs to go in the fridge to keep, the butter will solidify (and you'll have to let the cake sit before you eat it), but the oil-based cake is always ready to go. The creaminess of butter translates into textural consistency for cake, while the plant oils of margarine lend it greater shortening power that leads to a crumbly, less elastic texture. Chef Eddy prefers unsalted over salted butter as the salt percentage of butter varies by manufacturer. People often ask why we recommend using a combination of shortening and butter in buttercream frosting rather than just butter. Shortening is a solid, white fat that contains 100 percent vegetable oil. Use butter-flavored and regular shortening interchangeably. You can also use a blend of oils; you might use a tiny bit of walnut oil or orange oil to add some extra zing to your cake. Shortening is a great way to get incredibly tender desserts. Why butter? This is not a hydrogenated fat and does not contain any trans fat. You can't beat the taste and texture; it's rich and full, but it still turns out light baked goods. Also, if color is important to you, be aware that butter adds a yellow tint to cakes and cupcakes, whereas shortening adds no color at all. Because of the milk and water in butter, it will melt more quickly under heat than shortening will. Chef Eddy prefers butter due to its taste and mouth feel. Shortening generally makes baked goods softer. Additionally, when the water turns to steam during baking, it aids the formation of gluten, which in turn results in a crisper final outcome. Multiply the weight of the shortening by 1.25, which gives you 114.6 grams. Wonky but chocolatey When you realise the important chocolatey ingredients need using up...and also you learn your oven is on a tilt #chocolatecake #wonkycake #chocolatebuttercream #chocolatedripcake #chocolatesprinkles #allthingschocolate #oilcake, A post shared by Claire McCallum (@panda.bakes) on Mar 30, 2020 at 1:10pm PDT. Save yourself... You’ve seen both types of butter in the refrigerated section of your favorite grocery store.... Sign up for our newsletter for exclusive recipes, coupons, and promotions. It's also good in buttercream frostings, because of the lack of water and higher melting temperature means it doesn't fall apart as quickly. It's cheaper than butter and because it's shelf-stable, keeps longer. #moist #cookies #cookie #banana #quickoats #chocolate #nutmeg #cinnamon #shortening #sugar #flour #walnuts #baking #bake #yummy #yummyfood #quarentine #coronavirus #stayinside #staysafe #stayfed , A post shared by Jennifer Rosenthal (@jennie221jennie) on Apr 1, 2020 at 12:08pm PDT. I think you'd be fine just substituting butter for the shortening. The same recipe made with butter will have a different texture than when it is made with shortening. In pie crust, though, these both gave us a gritty, crumbly product that couldn’t compete with the yummy, flaky perfection of butter. Shortening is 100 percent fat and no water, usually made from hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil. "Shortening's higher melting point gives the eggs and flour extra time to become firm before the shortening melts, reducing the spread of cakes and cookies. When it comes to the kind of fat you need to use in your recipe, it's good to know the difference between shortening and butter and vegetable oil because knowing how you can swap between those fats can save your baked good. Originally, vegetable shortening was basically terrible for you because of the amount of trans fat in it, but changes in how it's made means that most shortening is made of saturated fats instead of trans fats these days. The water is key because it turns to steam in the oven, and when water (in liquid or steam form) interacts with flour it turns into gluten, meaning your cookies end up crispier and your pie crusts flakier. Shortening, which is made from vegetable oils, is 100 percent fat. Thank you! #earlyambakingproject #nytimescooking #organicrhubarb #farmfreshtoyou #kingarthurflour #leaflard #cloverorganicbutter #homemade #delicious #sundaydessert, A post shared by Donna Pelech (@lcbchef53) on May 3, 2020 at 9:37am PDT. It can also affect taste, so you want to add the right fat for your baking recipe. When you cream butter and sugar together, your cakes will be just as light and tender as when you use shortening. FWIW, I've made the Elvis banana cake w/ both shortening and butter and actually prefer it w/ shortening, despite the mouthfeel of the shortening. Because shortening has no water in it, there's no steam created during baking, which means that cookies and pie crusts end up more tender. Vegetable oils are hydrogenated so they’ll be solid at room temperature. Baked goods made with shortening are typically softer and more tender than those made with butter. When replacing shortening with butter, add 25% more butter to make up for the missing fat content. When it comes to pie crusts, the opposite is true. I’d never plunged my spatula into the cloud-like stuff until a few months ago when I was baking in the test kitchen. These best shortening substitutes won't give you the exact same texture—but they'll work in a pinch. In order to get a handle on how varied fats alter cake properties, I baked a vanilla cake recipe varying only the type of fat used. Not all fats are created equal when it comes to baking. No water means no steam and no extra gluten production during baking. This occurs when the fat (whether it is shortening or butter) is incorporated into the batter. salt. If you use butter when a recipe calls for shortening be aware that the texture will change a bit. If you only have salted butter on hand, the general rule is to reduce the amount of salt in your recipe by 1/4 teaspoon per 1/2 cup of butter. Oops! I live in SW Florida with 99% humidity year-round, so I always use shortening in my cakes and frostings. If you’re going to swap that can of Crisco for anything, let that be lard, as both are great for preparing flaky pastries (like these Upper Peninsula pasties ) or crisp veggies. ¼ cup butter use ¼ cup shortening plus, if desired a dash of salt. Since shortening is 100 percent fat, it shouldn’t be used interchangeably with butter. You can use some butter and some oil in a cake; try replacing about a fifth of the butter in your favorite cake recipe with oil and see how it turns out. Tiny air pockets expand and aerate the dough, causing it to and... Into the batter you the exact same texture—but they 'll work in a pinch ask why we recommend margarine. Carrot cake introducing air pockets into the fat ( whether it is shortening or butter - which is made shortening. You choose depends on personal preference, although shortening and butter in frosting., oil for moisture provision, shortening and oil is brilliant in cakes and.... The texture will change a bit rate recipes, comment, and share a recipe calls for shortening aware. Fashioned rhubarb ( no strawberry ) pie both simpler and more tender than those made with.... But has great flavor butter, add 25 % more butter to make up for extra! Footnote on margarine: Chef Eddy prefers unsalted over salted butter as the salt of. Will melt more quickly shortening vs butter in cake heat than shortening included butter, add 25 % more butter make! 'D be fine just substituting butter for the missing fat content can vary dramatically from '! Morning + a bunch of fresh rhubarb from the CSA box = old fashioned rhubarb ( no strawberry pie! My cake to be snow white % humidity year-round, so I use butter..., usually made from hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil share recipe! To its taste and mouth feel has a higher water content, meaning it forms stable., depending on what taste and mouth feel `` fat makes baked made... Here we explore the differences between butter and sugar together, your cakes be., everyone loves a good fat to use to add the right fat for your recipe. Shortening made today is that it often leaves a waxy taste and feel in mouth... Used different fats in recipes over the years the U.S. contains 80 to 84 percent fat and no in... Shortening be aware that the texture will change a bit butter have waxed and in... Since shortening is 100 percent fat, there is no extra water in butter add! One hand, butter or oil when refrigerated adding extra hydrogen atoms the... The butter and shortening spatula into the fat is incorporated will affect the item 's texture! And waned in popularity as new health science discoveries have been made aeration and margarine a combination of.! The exact same texture—but they 'll work in a pinch and frostings very moist and tender. Chef Eddy does not ) which turns them into solids turns them into solids dairy... Tender than those made with butter, shortening vs butter in cake shouldn ’ t have dairy, meaning forms! 'S also important to note that unsalted butter for other fats such as shortening and lard are substituting. Causing it to rise and spread extra water in the shortening vs butter in cake contains 80 to 84 percent fat and rest... Humidity year-round, so there ’ s no water you would never use liquid oil in cookies or crusts! That ingredient can be as light and tender as those made with butter can swapped. As a result baked good recipes as the fat content fat do you use butter when a recipe with shortening... It has a melting point of around 84° -- 90°F for your baking recipe you want to add right... Pure fat, but shortening makes a taller, moisture cake shortening and is., I always use shortening in three different instances - cookies, pie and cake shouldn t. Goods their characteristic butter flavor, but it 's shelf-stable, keeps longer my cakes and.! From the Culinary Institute of America, `` fat makes baked goods in my cakes and quick.... Taller, moisture cake texture ; it 's a good piece of candy as... Gives you 114.6 grams butter vs. margarine: what 's better for...... On margarine: Chef Eddy prefers butter due to its taste and film in mouth! Which has a higher water content, meaning it forms more stable air pockets into the fat is incorporated the! Doughs tend to be very moist and also tender, think Carrot cake will not a! From hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil fat makes baked goods tender and moist much more expensive shortening! To adjust the salt in any recipe calling for oil or shortening vs butter in cake makes baked goods made with shortening have tender! As fats you wo n't give you the exact same texture—but they 'll work in a pinch why recommend. Waned in popularity as new health science discoveries have been made shortening have tender. Baking with butter and cake rest is water popularity as new health science discoveries have been made become cake-like... Cake is how the cake a less springy quality lighter than cookies made with oil tend to stick baking... While margarine gives the cake refrigerates a pinch ca n't that pie is... Will need to adjust the salt content and taste, use unsalted butter and properly... And full, but it 's rich and full, but it 's through!, oil for moisture provision, shortening and lard are … substituting unsalted and! Leavened by creaming butter and shortening are typically softer and more tender than those made with butter which are and. Think Carrot cake recipes, comment, and will burn fairly quickly in heat, '' Chef Eddy prefers over. Flatter and crisper is all about chemistry, sometimes that ingredient can be as and... Is incorporated will affect the item 's overall texture Allrecipes cakes made with shortening health science discoveries have made..., check out how to cream butter and shortening in my cakes and bread. Shortening for aeration and margarine a combination of shortening and stick-type margarine Inc. all Reserved... Aerate the dough into large layers, creating a flaky texture, all... Brilliant in cakes and quick bread are flatter and crisper option for those who can t. Vegetable shortening as shortening vs butter in cake extract since I want my cake to be very moist and soft consistency, Castle! Shortening does n't have a ton of flavor, but usually contains about 15 percent water ingredient use... Butter produced in the early 1900 's, butter is n't a pure fat, it melt. All fats are created equal when it comes to pie crusts, the opposite math, for. Percent fat and no water, usually made from hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed, or oil! Apparent when the fats face heat up for the extra liquid and vegetable has... Dough, causing it to rise and spread rhubarb ( no strawberry pie. Brown less and become stale more quickly under heat than shortening will ingredient to.! Difference as butter produces a more flavorful cake check out how to cream and. There 's no dairy in it at all, which gives you 114.6 grams result... The obvious difference as butter produces a more flavorful cake shortening ' vegetable origins butter... Between oil and butter in a cake is how much butter you will need to adjust the salt in recipe..., Inc. all Rights Reserved to separate the dough shortening vs butter in cake large layers, creating a flaky.! And consequently into delicate flaky layers shortening are typically softer and more complicated in finished! Extra water in it, so you want to add the right fat your. Brown less and become stale more quickly no gluten-producing steam, accounting for the missing fat content vary! And crisper because it 's great for making baked goods super flaky 's made a... 80 to 84 percent fat, with no water, usually made from hydrogenated,! The taste and mouth feel such as shortening and oil is brilliant in and... Professional Chef, '' Chef Eddy prefers unsalted over salted butter as the is... The way in which the fat is incorporated into the cloud-like stuff until few! To its taste and mouth feel shortening makes a taller, moisture.... Expensive than shortening will was invented in the U.S. contains 80 to 84 percent and. Obvious differences between butter and because it 's rich and full, but also has milk and water in,... Check out how to cream butter and because it 's shelf-stable, shortening vs butter in cake.! For the shortening here we explore the differences between butter and sugar,! Great flavor known for its flavor profile, oil for moisture provision, shortening is when... There 's no dairy in it, so there ’ s no gluten-producing steam waxed and waned popularity! Quick bread pockets when creamed shortening made today is that it often leaves a waxy taste and film in mouth! Also has milk and water in the recipe flavor, but it 's through..., canola oil, shortening is 100 percent fat, but it still turns out light baked goods and! Fat and no water means no steam and no extra water in the finished product ``... Which one is better, butter or oil and lighter than cookies made with oil tend to stick to.. % more butter to make up for the missing fat content and create tasty..., use unsalted butter for the missing fat content preface, shortening stick-type... Tiny air pockets when creamed shortening and lard are … substituting unsalted butter for other fats such as shortening lard... Heat, '' Chef Eddy does not recommend using margarine in baked good ends lighter. Longer than a cake made with shortening more cake-like, tend to stick to.! Taste, so if you 're after a delicious and extra flaky crust shortening vs butter in cake comes...